In the world of football, transfer windows often bring about dramatic changes, and this summer's activity at Manchester City is no exception. With a whopping £458 million spent, City has not only broken the Premier League record for a summer window but also completely revamped its midfield.
What makes this particularly fascinating is the strategic approach taken by the club's new boss, Enzo Maresca, who received full support from the director of football, Hugo Viana. City's record transfer fee was doubled this summer, with a joint-British record of £125 million spent on Enzo Fernandez, followed by £116 million on Elliot Anderson, and £86 million on Ayyoub Bouaddi.
The departures of key players like Bernardo Silva, Rodri, and Nico Gonzalez have left a void in the midfield, but Maresca has filled these gaps with established talent. The club's sources are delighted with the business, especially considering the long-term planning that began in January 2025.
Just four players remain from the 2023 Champions League-winning squad, and Maresca now has the luxury of choosing from a strong and diverse squad. However, the big question remains: how will these new midfield signings fit together, and has City left itself vulnerable by not having a backup for star striker Erling Haaland?
Despite the impressive spending, City has also demonstrated its ability to sell fringe players for substantial fees, recouping £334 million in the same period. This includes the sale of Savinho for £75 million, despite his limited goal-scoring record at the club.
With a net spend of £208 million in 2026 and an obligation from Tottenham to buy Omar Marmoush for £60 million, City's financial strategy is impressive. The club believes it has addressed the departure of Nico Gonzalez by moving Nico O'Reilly into his natural midfield position.
The record fee for Fernandez is justified, according to City, as it brings a proven winner to strengthen the midfield. Anderson, a top target, and Bouaddi, a young talent, complete the midfield overhaul.
While City has started the Premier League season with two wins, the reliance on Haaland as the sole first-team striker is a concern. Should he be unavailable, City's options are limited, with Marmoush and Divin Mubama, who impressed in pre-season, now playing for other clubs.
City believes it has enough flexibility within its current squad, but the lack of a direct replacement for Marmoush is a risk. Semenyo, who primarily operates on the right flank, is seen as a potential option at number nine, but he has not reached double figures in the Premier League in recent seasons.
The same can be said for Cherki, Jeremy Doku, and Ndiaye, while Foden, despite his impressive 2023-24 season, has struggled for consistency. Unless these players step up, City may face challenges if Haaland needs a break or suffers an injury.
In my opinion, City's transfer strategy has been impressive, but the lack of depth in attack could be a potential weakness. The club's ability to balance spending and selling is a testament to its financial acumen, but the gamble on Haaland's availability may come back to haunt them if they don't address this issue soon.
